Much indistinct speech proceeded in respect to the Codex of Fatimah (upon whom be peace) known as ‘Mushaf Fatimah’. The enemies of the Ahl al-Bayt (upon whom be peace) sought to speak ill of the Shi‘a by accusing them that they have another Qur’an from which they derive the precepts of religion, which they call the ‘Codex of Fatimah’. This is what the enemies of the school of the Ahl al-Bayt (upon whom be peace) claim – which is a false accusation and is not worthy of any consideration. For the scholar will soon find the invalidity of these words when he refers to external reality of refers to the prooftexts reported from the Imams of the Ahl al-Bayt (upon whom be peace).
Moreover, the foregoing accusation is not new, or rather, it goes back to the area of the Umayyads and the Abbasids who were contemporary with the infallible Imams (upon whom be peace). What corroborates it are the reporters’ questions and the Imams’ replies as well as their declaration that deny categorically the Codex of Fatimah being another Qur’an.